pinellas · Bayway Isles Homeowners Club Inc

4934 58TH AVE S

Folio 09-32-16-05634-003-093010,454 sq ft lot
Records on file
20
Just value
$1,225,424
Assessed
$1,225,424
Upcoming hearings
None
OwnershipValue & salesPermitsRecorded documentsCode enforcementRiskAround hereComing upSourcesThis page is a tool, not an article. Every figure on it traces to the public source named beside it.
Watch this addressDouble opt-in. One email per new record. Unsubscribe deletes the row.
01

Ownership

PCPAO parcel layer · 31 Aug 2026, 05:06
Owner of record
OETTEL, PAMELA A
Owner type
individual
Mailing address
4934 58TH AVE S ST PETERSBURG FL 33715-1618
Exemption
None on the roll
Assessed equals taxable.

We show the owner name because it appears on the deed. We do not offer search by a person’s name.

02

Value & sales

Florida DOR sales file — dates at month precision · 31 Aug 2026, 00:26
No value history yet
The county publishes only the current tax roll, so this series is built from our own daily snapshots and starts the day we first saw this parcel. It fills in over time.
DatePriceInstrumentGrantor → granteeQualified
03 Jan 2020$780,00020837-0221ESTELIA MESIMER PA → LACH KATHLEEN M & OETTEL PAMELA AQualified
22 May 2019$530,00020555-0565MESIMER REGINALD → ESTELIA MESIMER PAUnqualified
21 Dec 2006$10015564-2295BOTT GERALD TR & GILLETT AMER TR BY TR → MESIMER, REGINALDUnqualified
20 Dec 2006$810,30015564-2293GILLETT J KATHLEEN TR & GILLETT AMER TR BY TR → MESIMER, REGINALDQualified
19 Mar 2004$013446-2054GILLETT C ANTHONY & GILLETT J KATHLEEN → GILLETT AMERICAN TRUSTUnqualified
13 Jan 1995$375,00008890-0794PANARO ROBERT J & PANARO M JATTALLEE → GILLETT, C. ANTHONY & GILLETT, J. KATHYQualified
26 Jan 1989$339,00006924-1725SMITH CHARLES F & SMITH VIRGINIA → PANARO, ROBERT J. & PANARO, M. JATTALLEEQualified
31 Oct 1981$245,00005259-1607Qualified
31 Dec 1978$157,00004704-0239Qualified
03

Permits

PCPAO RP_PERMITS · 31 Aug 2026, 07:21
PermitTypeDescriptionValuationDateStatus
23-11001132POOL$45,00017 Nov 2023Unknown
WND-21-01510DOCK$013 Dec 2021Unknown
21-03002011WINDOWS/DOORS$6,51731 Mar 2021Unknown
20-012000654CONC PAVE/DRIVEWAY$12,72009 Dec 2020Unknown
20-01001406AADDITION/REMODEL/RENOVATION$101,63215 Oct 2020Unknown
20-01001406ADDITION/REMODEL/RENOVATION$100,00005 Feb 2020Unknown
19-09000136WINDOWS/DOORS$19,38404 Sept 2019Unknown
18-09000373MISCELLANEOUS$1,59310 Sept 2018Unknown
04-4000843ROOF$26,28610 May 2004Unknown
P3266103DOCK$018 Mar 2003Unknown
P2446797DOCK$002 May 1997Unknown

Valuation is published for unincorporated county permits but not by the City of Tampa, which carries it on none of its permit layers — so the column is filled for some rows on the same parcel and not others. Contractor is published by neither. We show what each jurisdiction gives rather than estimating the rest.

04

Recorded documents

Pinellas Clerk — not yet ingested
Pinellas recorded documents are not covered yet
We ingest the Hillsborough Clerk’s daily index; the Pinellas Clerk’s equivalent is not yet built. An empty section here means we have not looked, not that nothing exists.
05

Code enforcement

Hillsborough County · 30 Aug 2026, 13:10
Pinellas code enforcement is not covered
Neither Pinellas County nor its cities publish a machine-readable code-case layer we can reach. An empty section here means we cannot see, not that nothing exists.
06

Risk

Pinellas County EMA Know Your Zone · FEMA NFHL · 30 Aug 2026, 11:54
FEMA flood zone
AE COASTAL FLOODPLAIN
Evacuation zone
A
Subsidence reports
No subsidence incidents reported within 1 mile. What this means
07

Around here

TPD calls for service · 05 Sept 2026, 10:02
Calls on nearby street segments, last 7 days
Police calls are not covered in Pinellas
We ingest Tampa Police’s published calls feed; no Pinellas agency publishes an equivalent we have found. Calls would be aggregated to the block here too.

No arrest records, no booking photographs, anywhere on this site.

Recent qualified sales within 200 m
AddressSoldPrice
5801 LEELAND ST S10 Apr 2026$1,305,000
4913 58TH AVE S27 Jan 2026$2,550,000
4900 59TH AVE S23 Jan 2026$3,100,000
5962 LEELAND ST S29 May 2025$1,040,000
02 Dec 2024$1,600,000
4750 BRITTANY DR S20 Nov 2024$480,000
4987 59TH AVE S04 Oct 2024$2,215,000
08

Coming up

Legistar matters + events · 05 Sept 2026, 06:15
Nothing scheduled
No rezoning, variance or special-use item names this parcel or folio on any agenda we have read. Hillsborough and Pinellas agendas are read every six hours; City of Tampa agendas have no API and are read by hand.
09

Sources for this page

SectionDatasetPublisherLegal basisLast fetch
Ownership, value, salesparcel + allsales extractHillsborough County Property AppraiserCh. 119 public record05 Sept 2026, 03:46
Recorded documentsDaily official records index (D / P / M)Hillsborough County Clerk of CourtCh. 119 public record05 Sept 2026, 03:01
PermitsPermitsAll + Construction InspectionsCity of Tampa GeoHubOpen data portal05 Sept 2026, 03:51
Around hereCalls for service (JSON)Tampa Police DepartmentCh. 119 public record05 Sept 2026, 10:02
Coming upLegistar matters / events APIHillsborough · PinellasPublic API, no key05 Sept 2026, 06:15
Code enforcementHillsborough County · City of TampaNo dataset publishedRequest open
Something here wrong, or should not be here?

Source data carries errors and we inherit them. If this is an address exempt under Fla. Stat. § 119.071(4)(d) — law enforcement, judges, prosecutors, survivors of domestic violence — we suppress the parcel within 48 hours, no questions asked.

Submit a correctionRequest suppression
Sunshine File

Built in Tampa from Florida public records under Chapter 119 and Art. I § 24. No mugshots. No search by a person’s name. No arrest records tied to individuals. Police calls are shown by block, never against a home.

Look up
Address fileNeighborhoodsZIP codes
The site
Data & methodologyPublic records logAboutContactPrivacyTerms
Theme
© 2026 Sunshine File · Tampa, FloridaThis site aggregates public records automatically. No article is AI-written.Not a consumer reporting agency. Do not use this information for employment, credit, housing, or insurance decisions (FCRA). · Report personal information on this page · Removal policy